Leaving a Legacy


The ‘so what’ of doctoral research

‘Doctoralness’.  Yet another new and rather splendid word – heard at the Prof.D ‘student guidelines’ lectures in January 2018.  What it means is a key test of the quality of doctoral research.  ‘Doctoralness’ is about how the work adds to society’s knowledge and organisational practice, from both theoretical and applied perspectives, the latter so very important in the Professional Doctorate route,

In short, it is the ‘so what?’ question.

There have been points in the doctoral journey where I have got stuck at a crossroads and wondered whether the stronger methodological focus of the traditional PhD is for me.  But I always come back to what really drives me – how we can create a better society.  And although I believe that academic research has a huge role to play in that, it is agents which bring  about change.  Hence the importance of continually asking ‘so what?’

Legitimacy and legacy

During the lectures, we discussed how motivations can alter over the doctoral programme.  For me, the sense of confidence, of life purpose, and also, my ‘legitimacy’ as a practitioner, and not just as an academic, have all intensified.

But what of having ‘something to prove’, often a motivation for later life doctorates, as the tutor explained, compared to young post-Master candidates.  Thinking about my long Council career which ended with a kind of ‘fizzling out’ rather than at a high point, I have reflected on this and think there is much truth in my need at some level to ‘prove’ my intellectual capacity and capability. Legacy is important to us all but we can leave a legacy in many ways, not just by being promoted to higher positions in the staff hierarchy.  So, having given several decades to local government, which I fundamentally believe to be a force for good, I care very much about making a mark in my professional field.  It is just not me to walk away and make my mark in some other domain.

Reducing the expanding universe

I know that I face real challenges with my chosen methodological approach – discourse analysis – in how I will make my research meaningful to my professional field.  Complicating things is that my field is wedded to positivist thinking, causal studies and quantitative analysis.  At its simplest, the basic ideas surrounding discourse analysis – language in use and the meanings we ascribe to it – isn’t difficult, but like many concepts, it is in their theoretical application where things can become opaque.

David Hume statue and St Giles Cathedral, High Street copy

At this stage of embarking on the thesis stage, I have what my supervisor cheerfully calls an ‘expanding universe’. I am reassured that this is normal for early stage doctoral students and one which, in time, will reduce to the admittedly tiny addition to knowledge which is feasible within the 4-5 year timeframe.  It is small comfort to learn that some academics spend many years framing their proposal and working out a method which will address their questions.

But what we prof docs have as our key advantage, is the knowledge of our professional fields. That deep cultural understanding is one which can only be gained through work experience.  Of course it also sets up our biases and ‘baggage’ but, provided we acknowledge this in stated limitations, it gives us a tremendous head start.  I will hold onto this thought as I pick up my literature review again and begin to structure my chapter headings for the 60,000 words which lie ahead of me!

Next:  Preparing for my first academic conference

5 thoughts on “Leaving a Legacy

  1. What a fabulous article Lesley!

    Not only will it contribute to your own learning, but to that of others’ too.

    For me, ‘Doctoralness’ needs to be about more than how the work contributes to sciety, but to wider ecology and the environment; especially as we face the increasinly challenging climate change


  2. What a fabulous article Lesley!

    Not only will it contribute to your own learning, but to that of others. This goes beyond the mundane, superficial motivators for pusruing a Doctoral degree.

    For me, ‘Doctoralness’ needs to be more about generating social and cultural capital. In a time of increasing challenges posed by climate change, leaving a legacy from our doctoral thesis work, is, for me, about changing social praxis to genterate wider ecological and envoronmental capital; i.e. stop destroying this finite resource we call planet Earth!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Lesley, your comment about contributing to a better society is well stated and having also left a full-time career in industry to focus on my teaching and research interests, I appreciate your sentiments. I feel that while my career as a Project and Programme Manager has served me well, its now time to focus more on giving back to society. I’m very lucky to teach part-time on modules related to project management and sustainable development but I want my legacy to be more than that, hence I’m currently studying digital education and trying to figure out what my contribution to society will be. Ideally a doctorate in education / social justice / lifelong learning but the pathway is not yet clear. In the meantime I will follow your #profdockers movement with interest.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s